Mumbai Got It Wrong

The 3rd edition of the IPL ended yesterday with the Chennai Super Kings being crowned champions. It was a fitting result for the Super Kings, who have been the most consistent team in the 3 editions, reaching the semi finals on each occasion,  the only team to do so. They also lost the first final by one run to the Rajasthan Royals. With the end of the 3rd edition signally the end of the teams first window together, there will be a fresh auction where the teams will be reshuffled and joined by two new teams, Chennai were rewarded for their results in the first three years. How different it could have been had Munbai got their tactics right.

The Mumbai Indians were the most expensive team at the beginning of the IPL. Bringing in the likes of Tendulkar, Harbajhan Singh, Shaun Pollock, JP Duminy and Dwayne Bravo. The first two editions saw them flatter to deceive and fail to reach the semi’s both times. This year things were different. The balance of the team was perhaps the best of the 8 teams. In Pollard, their expensive new acquisition, they had a powerful all-rounder who could finish games off for them. They sailed through the group stages, easily topping the log, and lead by the magnificent, and ageless, Tendulkar, and the simply brilliant Malinga.  There blend of local and overseas players gave them depth in all area’s, and little weakness. But when it really mattered they came unstuck.

Firstly they had Chennai on the ropes, and then fluffed it, dropping Raina twice on his way to a match winning 50. They allowed Chennai to post a decent score on a wicket that was always going to be harder chasing on. Their biggest mistakes came with their batting line up. When they were chasing 14-16 an over, with 6 overs to go, they should have sent Pollard in. Instead they waited until the 17th over, where his big hitting cameo showed what could have been, and not what was too late. Duminy, who is well capable of clearing the ropes, his brilliant 99* in the Champions League was evident of that, is not a hitter from ball one. He needs an over to play himself in, and coming in when he did he wasnt afforded that. His success in this format has been built around opening the batting, or coming in higher than what he has been doing lately. Last season he was Mumbai’s top run scorer, and that was from the to of the order. Why he wasn’t opening with Tendulkar, or at least coming in at 3 or 4, is something that Mumbai should look at.

The real crime was waiting till the match was all but lost to send Pollard in. It was simply asking too much to expect him to single-handedly win them the match with so few balls left. valiantly he attempted to do just that, but in vain, with a brilliant piece of captaincy by Dhoni, and an excellent 19th over by Morkel, winning the game for Chennai.

So was we move to the next phase of the IPL, with the auction and the reshaping of the teams, it will be interesting to see what happens. The teams have all had 3 years to work things out, and to see which players excel and which don’t. We’ll have to sit back and let it all unfold, but it should be the most interesting window in the IPL to date. For Chennai, they will know that there 3 years have culminated in a win, while Mumbai will now start again, knowing what it takes, and hoping not to repeat the mistakes of the past.

pic from cricinfo


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: